Head-to-Head Comparison
Amherst College vs Carnegie Mellon University
- Amherst Wins
- 20
- Tied
- 14
- Carnegie Mellon Wins
- 18
Direct Answer
For overall financial value, Amherst College offers a significantly safer investment tier. While Carnegie Mellon University achieves a higher graduation rate (94% vs 93%), its annual cost of attendance sits at $35,780 compared to Amherst College's $19,536. For students prioritizing lower student debt over initial institution prestige, Amherst College's lower price point delivers a highly efficient debt-to-earnings path.
52 data points compared · Sources: College Scorecard, Opportunity Insights, Times Higher Education, IPEDS
When to Pick Each School
Amherst
- Lower cost: Average net price of $19,536, roughly $16,244 a year less
- Less debt: Median debt of $13,250, the lower of the two
- More selective: Admits 9% of applicants, which makes for a more competitive peer group
Carnegie Mellon
- Higher earnings: Median earnings of $125,257 ten years after enrollment, 32% more than Amherst College
- Social mobility: Chetty mobility rate of 2.2%, the stronger record of moving students up the income ladder
The Actual Decision
What are you really choosing between?
Amherst graduates concentrate in Social Sciences (20% of degrees); Carnegie Mellon in Engineering (23%). If you already know the field you want, the choice is mostly made for you.
Based on each school's share of degrees by field (College Scorecard). It shows where graduates actually concentrate, not the only path a school offers.
Which School Fits You?
Pick Carnegie Mellon University over Amherst College. Median earnings of $125,257 ten years after enrollment vs $95,161.
Pick Amherst College over Carnegie Mellon University. Net price $19,536 vs $35,780.
Pick Carnegie Mellon University over Amherst College. 2.2% mobility rate vs 2%.
Key Metrics at a Glance
Graduation Rate
Earnings (10yr)
Avg Net Price
Median Debt
The Analysis
Verdict
Amherst College and Carnegie Mellon University split the core measures almost evenly. Neither comes out a clean winner, so the choice rests on which of these dimensions you care about most.
Getting in
Amherst College is the harder admit. It takes 9% of applicants, while Carnegie Mellon University takes 12%. Its entering class also posts the higher average SAT, 1,533 to 1,546.
So what: If test scores and a high-scoring peer group matter to you, Amherst College sets the higher bar. The less selective school is easier to get into, which can work in your favor rather than against it.
What it costs
On price, Amherst College comes out ahead. Its average net price after aid is $19,536, about $16,244 a year below Carnegie Mellon University's $35,780. Graduates of Amherst College also borrow less: median debt of $13,250, against $19,000.
So what: Over four years, the gap adds up to about $64,976 before any change in aid. Choosing Amherst College leaves that money available for graduate school, savings, or simply less borrowing.
What graduates earn
Ten years after enrollment, Carnegie Mellon University graduates report median earnings of $125,257, compared with $95,161 at Amherst College. That is a 32% advantage. Set against borrowing, Amherst College has the lower debt-to-earnings ratio, 0.14x to 0.15x.
So what: An earnings gap of 32% this early in a career tends to widen, since raises build on the higher base. Of the measures on this page, this one carries the most financial weight.
Moving people up
Carnegie Mellon University does more to move students up the income ladder. Its Chetty mobility rate is 2.2%; at Amherst College, it is 2%. Amherst College also enrolls the larger share of low-income students: 4.2% come from the bottom income quintile, versus 4.1%.
So what: For first-generation and low-income students, Carnegie Mellon University offers the stronger statistical shot at reaching the top of the income distribution. The gap is wide enough to weigh in any access-minded decision.
Recommendation
Bottom line: pick Amherst College to keep costs and debt down; pick Carnegie Mellon University for the higher earnings ceiling.
Data certainty: High. Both schools report 6 of 6 core signals used here, so every comparison above matches reported data against reported data.
Counterintuitive Insights
The cheaper school is not the lower-earning one here. Amherst College saves about $16,244 a year, yet Carnegie Mellon University graduates earn $30,096 more ten years after enrollment. The cost advantage and the earnings premium sit at different schools, so your time horizon decides which counts more.
Amherst College is harder to get into, with a 9% admit rate, but Carnegie Mellon University posts the higher mobility rate, at 2.2%. Selectivity and income mobility measure different things; here, the easier admit does more for the low-income students it enrolls.
Their academic identities diverge. Amherst College concentrates enrollment in Social Sciences, Biology & Biomedical, while Carnegie Mellon University leans toward Engineering, Mathematics & Statistics. That split shapes which recruiters come to campus and what your classmates study.
Who Should Look Elsewhere
- STEM and CS-focused students: tech programs are a smaller part of Amherst College's enrollment, and Carnegie Mellon University is stronger here.
- Cost-conscious students: net price of $35,780 runs well above Amherst College's $19,536.
- Students minimizing debt: median debt is $19,000, against $13,250 at Amherst College.
- Students who want a smaller campus: Carnegie Mellon University's enrollment of 7,304 far exceeds Amherst College's 1,911.
Full Data Breakdown
Inside the admissions office
Carnegie Mellon holds onto its admits more tightly: 46% of admitted students enroll, versus 39% at Amherst — a sign of how often it wins head-to-head choices. Both reward applying early, but the binding round pays off more at Amherst (29.4% Early Decision admit rate vs 23.1%). Early Decision is binding, so it only makes sense if the school is a clear first choice.
Source: each school's published Common Data Set, via collegedata.fyi.
Overview 5 metrics
Admissions 4 metrics
Admissions Strategy (Common Data Set) 4 metrics
Cost & Financial Aid 9 metrics
Academics 5 metrics
Student Body 6 metrics
Outcomes 6 metrics
Social Mobility (Chetty) 4 metrics
Social Capital 3 metrics
Research (Times HE) 4 metrics
Online Education (IPEDS) 2 metrics
The Overviews
Amherst College
Amherst, MA · Private nonprofit
With an acceptance rate of just 9%, Amherst College attracts students who are academically driven and eager to engage in a close-knit learning environment. This college is a great fit for those interested in fields like Social Sciences, Biology, Computer Science, Mathematics, and Physical Sciences. The small student body of around 1,911 fosters a sense of community, making it easier for students to connect with faculty and peers while diving deep into their studies.
After graduation, students can expect to earn an impressive average of $77,644 within ten years. This figure reflects the strong outcomes for graduates, many of whom find opportunities to advance in their careers. While the Pell Grant rate sits at 20%, indicating support for lower-income students, the emphasis remains on ensuring that all graduates can make strides in their professional lives without being overly burdened by financial constraints.
In terms of affordability, the net price after aid comes to about $23,367, with a median debt of $13,740 for those who do take loans. This financial picture suggests that students who thrive here often come from a variety of backgrounds but share a common commitment to their education. With a graduation rate of 94%, it’s clear that students who choose Amherst tend to find their place and succeed, making the investment in their education worthwhile.
Carnegie Mellon University
Pittsburgh, PA · Private nonprofit
With an acceptance rate of just 12%, Carnegie Mellon University is a great fit for students who are ready to dive into rigorous academic programs. This school attracts those passionate about fields like Engineering, Computer Science, and Business. The blend of technical and creative disciplines, including Visual and Performing Arts, creates a unique environment where students can thrive while exploring their varied interests.
Life after graduation at Carnegie Mellon looks promising. Graduates can expect to earn an impressive average of $114,862 within ten years of completing their degrees. This strong earning potential is crucial for students weighing their options, as it reflects the value of the education they receive here. With a graduation rate of 93%, it’s clear that students are not only getting in but are also navigating their studies successfully.
When considering the financial aspect, the net price after aid is around $31,944, which can feel daunting but is manageable compared to potential earnings. The median debt for graduates stands at $21,750, suggesting that many students are able to graduate with a reasonable level of debt. Students who tend to thrive here are those who are dedicated, ambitious, and ready to engage deeply with their chosen fields.
Rankings They Appear On
Carnegie Mellon University is featured on the Best Computer Science Colleges in Pennsylvania ranking.
Top Degree Programs
Amherst's top program is Sociology (20% of enrollment), while Carnegie Mellon leads with Mechanical Engineering (23%).
Career Pathways
Program strengths at these schools feed into careers like Software Developer, Data Scientist, Cybersecurity Analyst (for Amherst) and Software Developer, Data Scientist, Cybersecurity Analyst (for Carnegie Mellon).
The two schools feed different job markets. Amherst College is strongest in Social Sciences, Biology & Biomedical, while Carnegie Mellon University concentrates in Engineering, Business & Marketing. Those concentrations determine which recruiters show up on campus and where alumni cluster by industry. Match the school's program strengths to the field you plan to enter.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it harder to get into Amherst College or Carnegie Mellon University?
Amherst College is harder to get into, admitting 9% of applicants compared with 12% at Carnegie Mellon University.
Which is more affordable, Amherst College or Carnegie Mellon University?
Amherst College is more affordable, with an average net price of $19,536 after aid versus $35,780 at Carnegie Mellon University.
Do Amherst College or Carnegie Mellon University graduates earn more?
Carnegie Mellon University graduates earn more: median earnings of $125,257 ten years after enrollment, versus $95,161 at Amherst College.
Which has a better graduation rate, Amherst College or Carnegie Mellon University?
Carnegie Mellon University has the higher graduation rate, 94% versus 93%.
Amherst College vs Carnegie Mellon University: which is better for social mobility?
Carnegie Mellon University is the stronger driver of upward mobility, with a Chetty mobility rate of 2.2% versus 2%.
Should you choose Amherst College or Carnegie Mellon University?
It depends on what you weigh most. Choose Amherst College if affordability and lower debt come first; choose Carnegie Mellon University if you're optimizing for post-grad earnings. The two schools win on different measures, so the better fit is the one whose strengths match your priorities.
More Comparisons
View all →Weigh Your Options
Best Colleges in America
How do Amherst and Carnegie Mellon stack up against regional and national alternatives when evaluated on pure socioeconomic mobility, graduate earnings, and long-term return on investment? Explore the full, verified dataset on our comprehensive rankings directory.