Skip to content
CollegeRanker

Rankings / By State

Best Online Colleges in West Virginia

By David Krug, Co-Founder, CollegeRanker Updated 2026-07-20 23 schools Agent Insights
23
Schools
$41,349
Avg. Earnings
39%
Avg. Graduation
$10,841
Avg. Net Price
$16,798
Avg. Debt

CollegeRanker Research

What Surprised Us Most

  1. Graduate earnings span a wide band on this list, from $24,900 at the low end to $57,949 at the top. That 2.3× spread shows how much outcomes vary within a single category.

  2. West Virginia University at Parkersburg offers the strongest payback. Graduates earn a median of $35,171 against $1,807 in annual net price, the best earnings-to-cost ratio in this ranking.

  3. The most budget-friendly option on this list is West Virginia University at Parkersburg, at $1,807 annually in net price.

  4. Completion rates separate this field: West Virginia University graduates 63% of its students, well above the 39% list average. Finishing what you start matters as much as where you start.

  5. Debt-to-earnings ratios favor New River Community and Technical College: graduates owe only 0.25× their yearly income, the most manageable debt burden on the list.

Surprising Comparisons

The Takeaway

The schools that win this ranking are not the priciest or the most selective. They turn students into earners without burying them in debt, which is exactly what our outcomes-first methodology is built to surface.

What This Means for Students

If you are choosing from this list, start with West Virginia University at Parkersburg and West Virginia University. Pull each school's net price for your income band, weigh projected earnings against the debt you would take on, and let payoff rather than prestige drive your shortlist.

Why this ranking matters

These schools are ranked on outcomes that compound: graduate earnings, upward mobility, debt, and value, all drawn from federal tax records and Scorecard data rather than reputation surveys. The list rewards results over prestige, led by institutions whose graduates earn a median of about $39K ten years after enrollment.

How we measure this — full methodology →

How we rank · 4 pillars

Economic outcomes30%
Social mobility35%
Value (earnings vs. cost)20%
Academic quality15%

Federal-source data only. Build your own weighting →

$39K
Median grad earnings
10 yrs after entry
39%
Average graduation rate
Across the list
$11K
Average net price
After grants/aid
84%
Average admit rate
Selectivity
Data Behind This Page Updated 2026-07-20
23 institutions ranked
2026-07-20 Last updated
100% Public / federal sources

Source datasets

Methodology

Schools are scored on the CollegeRanker 4-Pillar Algorithm: Economic Outcomes (30%), Social Mobility (25–35%), Academic Quality (15–20%), and Value (20–25%). Every weight is published and every figure traces to a public dataset.

See the full methodology and weights →

Confidence notes

  • Earnings, completion, and debt figures come from federal administrative records — tax data and student-aid filings — not surveys or self-reports, the highest-confidence tier of education data available.
  • Social-mobility estimates are drawn from de-identified tax records covering more than 30 million students (Opportunity Insights).
  • Where an institution is missing a metric, it is excluded from that metric rather than imputed, so averages are never inflated by guesses.

Limitations

  • Federal earnings data primarily cover students who received federal financial aid; outcomes for non-aided students may differ.
  • Earnings are measured roughly ten years after enrollment, so they describe how earlier cohorts fared — historical outcomes, not guarantees of future results.
  • An institution's field-of-study mix affects raw earnings; scores reflect measured outcomes and are not fully major-adjusted unless explicitly noted.
  • Net price is an average; the actual cost a given student pays varies widely by family income.

At a Glance

How the Top Schools Compare

School Earnings Net Price Graduation Score
$55,939
▲ +35% vs avg
$15,634 63%
68
2
Marshall University
#2 overall
$46,354
▲ +12% vs avg
$7,502 50%
68
3
Shepherd University
#3 overall
$49,358
▲ +19% vs avg
$11,363 50%
68
$42,703
▲ +3% vs avg
$9,966 41%
68
$55,774
▲ +35% vs avg
$22,107 46%
66

Score uses our 4-pillar methodology. Earnings % is vs. this list's average.

See full ranking →

Executive Summary

Best Online Colleges in West Virginia

This analysis ranks 23 institutions on graduate earnings, social mobility, completion, and cost. Across the list, alumni earn a median of $41,349 ten years after enrolling, against an average graduation rate of 39% and an average net price of $10,841.

Key takeaways

Our Analysis Found

110%
Private nonprofit colleges cost 110% more in net price than publics, while their graduates earn 21% more.
CollegeRanker examined 5,745 U.S. colleges and found (n=3,655). Mean net price and mean 10-year earnings by ownership type (College Scorecard).

Access & Flexibility Analysis

What does this ranking tell us about online education and the working-adult learner?

$39,315

Median earnings (10yr)

36%

Median graduation rate

$9,337

Median net price

1.4%

Avg. mobility rate

The online education market has matured. What was once a niche offering for non-traditional students is now a central way Americans access higher education. The programs that succeed pair flexibility with the support structures and academic rigor that lead to completion and career outcomes rather than enrollment alone.

Across the 23 schools on this list, graduates earn a median of $39,315 ten years after they first enrolled. The median graduation rate is 36%. Net price, what students pay after grants, runs a median of $9,337 a year, with about $18,900 in median federal debt at graduation. An average of 36% of students receive Pell grants, and the typical school moves low-income students into the top income quintile at a rate of 1.4%.

Online delivery is no longer a compromise; the best programs post outcomes competitive with their on-campus peers. With median earnings of $39,315 and a net price of $9,337, these programs show that flexibility and quality can coexist.

The podium

Build your ranking

Drag a pillar — schools re-rank live.

Academic 15%
Economic 30%
Social mobility 35%
Value 20%

Tip: Check the box on any 2–4 schools below to compare them side by side.

Full rankings

1
·
West Virginia University

Morgantown, WV · 89% accepted · $15,634 net

68

Why it ranks #1

West Virginia University lands at #1 with a 68/100 composite, led by social mobility (78/100) and pulled down by value per dollar (63/100). Graduates earn a median $55,939 a decade after enrolling, 35% above this list's average, and net price runs $15,634 a year, above the field. Because the methodology weights social mobility (35%) and value (20%) above prestige, that mobility is what puts it near the top.

Pillar breakdown

Academic
68
Economic
66
Social mobility
78
Value
63
View full profile →
2
·
Marshall University

Huntington, WV · 96% accepted · $7,502 net

68

Why it ranks #2

Marshall University lands at #2 with a 68/100 composite, led by social mobility (82/100) and pulled down by academic quality (60/100). Graduates earn a median $46,354 a decade after enrolling, 12% above this list's average, and net price runs $7,502 a year, well under the field. Because the methodology weights social mobility (35%) and value (20%) above prestige, that mobility is what puts it near the top.

Pillar breakdown

Academic
60
Economic
60
Social mobility
82
Value
73
View full profile →
3
·
Shepherd University

Shepherdstown, WV · 97% accepted · $11,363 net

68

Why it ranks #3

Shepherd University lands at #3 with a 68/100 composite, led by social mobility (82/100) and pulled down by academic quality (58/100). Graduates earn a median $49,358 a decade after enrolling, 19% above this list's average, and net price runs $11,363 a year. Because the methodology weights social mobility (35%) and value (20%) above prestige, that mobility is what puts it near the top.

Pillar breakdown

Academic
58
Economic
63
Social mobility
82
Value
68
View full profile →
4
·
Concord University

Athens, WV · 93% accepted · $9,966 net

68

Why it ranks #4

Concord University lands at #4 with a 68/100 composite, led by social mobility (85/100) and pulled down by academic quality (57/100). Graduates earn a median $42,703 a decade after enrolling, 3% above this list's average, and net price runs $9,966 a year. Because the methodology weights social mobility (35%) and value (20%) above prestige, that mobility is what puts it near the top.

Pillar breakdown

Academic
57
Economic
60
Social mobility
85
Value
69
View full profile →
5
·
University of Charleston

Charleston, WV · 62% accepted · $22,107 net

66

Why it ranks #5

University of Charleston lands at #5 with a 66/100 composite, led by social mobility (90/100) and pulled down by value per dollar (53/100). Graduates earn a median $55,774 a decade after enrolling, 35% above this list's average, and net price runs $22,107 a year, above the field. Because the methodology weights social mobility (35%) and value (20%) above prestige, that mobility is what puts it near the top.

Pillar breakdown

Academic
59
Economic
67
Social mobility
90
Value
53
View full profile →
6
·
West Liberty University

West Liberty, WV · 97% accepted · $15,366 net

65

Why it ranks #6

West Liberty University lands at #6 with a 65/100 composite, led by social mobility (82/100) and pulled down by economic outcomes (59/100). Graduates earn a median $43,296 a decade after enrolling, 5% above this list's average, and net price runs $15,366 a year, above the field. Because the methodology weights social mobility (35%) and value (20%) above prestige, that mobility is what puts it near the top.

Pillar breakdown

Academic
61
Economic
59
Social mobility
82
Value
60
View full profile →
7
·
West Virginia State University

Institute, WV · 96% accepted · $11,139 net

65

Why it ranks #7

West Virginia State University lands at #7 with a 65/100 composite, led by social mobility (79/100) and pulled down by academic quality (54/100). Graduates earn a median $40,492 a decade after enrolling, 2% below this list's average, and net price runs $11,139 a year. Because the methodology weights social mobility (35%) and value (20%) above prestige, that mobility is what puts it near the top, even with below-average salaries.

Pillar breakdown

Academic
54
Economic
56
Social mobility
79
Value
70
View full profile →
8
·
Bluefield State University

Bluefield, WV · 97% accepted · $13,684 net

64

Why it ranks #8

Bluefield State University lands at #8 with a 64/100 composite, led by social mobility (81/100) and pulled down by academic quality (51/100). Graduates earn a median $38,217 a decade after enrolling, 8% below this list's average, and net price runs $13,684 a year, above the field. Because the methodology weights social mobility (35%) and value (20%) above prestige, that mobility is what puts it near the top, even with below-average salaries.

Pillar breakdown

Academic
51
Economic
59
Social mobility
81
Value
62
View full profile →
9
·
West Virginia Northern Community College

Wheeling, WV · $5,329 net

64

Why it ranks #9

West Virginia Northern Community College lands at #9 with a 64/100 composite, led by value per dollar (86/100) and pulled down by academic quality (41/100). Graduates earn a median $30,162 a decade after enrolling, 27% below this list's average, and net price runs $5,329 a year, well under the field. Because the methodology weights social mobility (35%) and value (20%) above prestige, that low cost is what puts it near the top, even with below-average salaries.

Pillar breakdown

Academic
41
Economic
58
Social mobility
80
Value
86
View full profile →
10
·
63

Why it ranks #10

Southern West Virginia Community and Technical College lands at #10 with a 63/100 composite, led by social mobility (83/100) and pulled down by academic quality (40/100). Graduates earn a median $32,153 a decade after enrolling, 22% below this list's average, and net price runs $10,321 a year. Because the methodology weights social mobility (35%) and value (20%) above prestige, that mobility is what puts it near the top, even with below-average salaries.

Pillar breakdown

Academic
40
Economic
59
Social mobility
83
Value
78
View full profile →
11
·
Glenville State University

Glenville, WV · $14,006 net

60

Why it ranks #11

Glenville State University lands at #11 with a 60/100 composite, led by social mobility (83/100) and pulled down by academic quality (47/100). Graduates earn a median $39,315 a decade after enrolling, 5% below this list's average, and net price runs $14,006 a year, above the field. Because the methodology weights social mobility (35%) and value (20%) above prestige, that mobility is what carries it up the list, even with below-average salaries.

Pillar breakdown

Academic
47
Economic
55
Social mobility
83
Value
61
View full profile →
12
·
West Virginia University Institute of Technology

Beckley, WV · 37% accepted · $9,337 net

59

Why it ranks #12

West Virginia University Institute of Technology lands at #12 with a 59/100 composite, led by value per dollar (73/100) and pulled down by academic quality (52/100). Graduates earn a median $55,939 a decade after enrolling, 35% above this list's average, and net price runs $9,337 a year, well under the field. Because the methodology weights social mobility (35%) and value (20%) above prestige, that low cost is what carries it up the list.

Pillar breakdown

Academic
52
Economic
66
Social mobility
58
Value
73
View full profile →
13
·
Fairmont State University

Fairmont, WV · 99% accepted · $9,032 net

58

Why it ranks #13

Fairmont State University lands at #13 with a 58/100 composite, led by value per dollar (70/100) and pulled down by social mobility (58/100). Graduates earn a median $46,857 a decade after enrolling, 13% above this list's average, and net price runs $9,032 a year, well under the field. Because the methodology weights social mobility (35%) and value (20%) above prestige, that low cost is what carries it up the list.

Pillar breakdown

Academic
60
Economic
61
Social mobility
58
Value
70
View full profile →
14
·
BridgeValley Community & Technical College

South Charleston, WV · $4,565 net

56

Why it ranks #14

BridgeValley Community & Technical College lands at #14 with a 56/100 composite, led by value per dollar (84/100) and pulled down by academic quality (38/100). Graduates earn a median $36,432 a decade after enrolling, 12% below this list's average, and net price runs $4,565 a year, well under the field. Because the methodology weights social mobility (35%) and value (20%) above prestige, that low cost is what carries it up the list, even with below-average salaries.

Pillar breakdown

Academic
38
Economic
63
Social mobility
60
Value
84
View full profile →
15
·
Wheeling University

Wheeling, WV · 63% accepted · $20,503 net

56

Why it ranks #15

Wheeling University lands at #15 with a 56/100 composite, led by economic outcomes (66/100) and pulled down by value per dollar (49/100). Graduates earn a median $57,949 a decade after enrolling, 40% above this list's average, and net price runs $20,503 a year, above the field. Strong earnings drive the rank, but with mobility weighted 35% and value 20%, salary alone can only take a school so far.

Pillar breakdown

Academic
58
Economic
66
Social mobility
60
Value
49
View full profile →
16
·
55

Why it ranks #16

New River Community and Technical College lands at #16 with a 55/100 composite, led by value per dollar (89/100) and pulled down by academic quality (46/100). Graduates earn a median $29,073 a decade after enrolling, 30% below this list's average, and net price runs $3,599 a year, well under the field. Because the methodology weights social mobility (35%) and value (20%) above prestige, that low cost is what carries it up the list, even with below-average salaries.

Pillar breakdown

Academic
46
Economic
60
Social mobility
53
Value
89
View full profile →
17
·
Blue Ridge Community and Technical College

Martinsburg, WV · $4,641 net

55

Why it ranks #17

Blue Ridge Community and Technical College lands at #17 with a 55/100 composite, led by value per dollar (85/100) and pulled down by social mobility (48/100). Graduates earn a median $39,293 a decade after enrolling, 5% below this list's average, and net price runs $4,641 a year, well under the field. Because the methodology weights social mobility (35%) and value (20%) above prestige, that low cost is what carries it up the list, even with below-average salaries.

Pillar breakdown

Academic
53
Economic
63
Social mobility
48
Value
85
View full profile →
18
·
54

Why it ranks #18

Potomac State College of West Virginia University lands at #18 with a 54/100 composite, led by value per dollar (72/100) and pulled down by academic quality (48/100). Graduates earn a median $55,939 a decade after enrolling, 35% above this list's average, and net price runs $9,197 a year, well under the field. Because the methodology weights social mobility (35%) and value (20%) above prestige, that low cost is what carries it up the list.

Pillar breakdown

Academic
48
Economic
66
Social mobility
52
Value
72
View full profile →
19
·
53

Why it ranks #19

Eastern West Virginia Community and Technical College lands at #19 with a 53/100 composite, led by value per dollar (83/100) and pulled down by academic quality (41/100). Graduates earn a median $31,636 a decade after enrolling, 23% below this list's average, and net price runs $8,095 a year, well under the field. Because the methodology weights social mobility (35%) and value (20%) above prestige, that low cost is what carries it up the list, even with below-average salaries.

Pillar breakdown

Academic
41
Economic
64
Social mobility
47
Value
83
View full profile →
20
·
Mountwest Community and Technical College

Huntington, WV · $8,083 net

51

Why it ranks #20

Mountwest Community and Technical College lands at #20 with a 51/100 composite, led by value per dollar (80/100) and pulled down by academic quality (34/100). Graduates earn a median $28,951 a decade after enrolling, 30% below this list's average, and net price runs $8,083 a year, well under the field. Because the methodology weights social mobility (35%) and value (20%) above prestige, that low cost is what carries it up the list, even with below-average salaries.

Pillar breakdown

Academic
34
Economic
61
Social mobility
50
Value
80
View full profile →
21
·
West Virginia University at Parkersburg

Parkersburg, WV · $1,807 net

50

Why it ranks #21

West Virginia University at Parkersburg lands at #21 with a 50/100 composite, led by value per dollar (88/100) and pulled down by academic quality (23/100). Graduates earn a median $35,171 a decade after enrolling, 15% below this list's average, and net price runs $1,807 a year, well under the field. Because the methodology weights social mobility (35%) and value (20%) above prestige, that low cost is what carries it up the list, even with below-average salaries.

Pillar breakdown

Academic
23
Economic
59
Social mobility
55
Value
88
View full profile →
22
·
Pierpont Community and Technical College

Fairmont, WV · $8,325 net

47

Why it ranks #22

Pierpont Community and Technical College lands at #22 with a 47/100 composite, led by value per dollar (79/100) and pulled down by social mobility (27/100). Graduates earn a median $35,132 a decade after enrolling, 15% below this list's average, and net price runs $8,325 a year, well under the field. Because the methodology weights social mobility (35%) and value (20%) above prestige, that low cost is what carries it up the list, even with below-average salaries.

Pillar breakdown

Academic
57
Economic
63
Social mobility
27
Value
79
View full profile →
23
·
Valley College-Martinsburg

Martinsburg, WV · $25,751 net

44

Why it ranks #23

Valley College-Martinsburg lands at #23 with a 44/100 composite, led by academic quality (61/100) and pulled down by value per dollar (41/100). Graduates earn a median $24,900 a decade after enrolling, 40% below this list's average, and net price runs $25,751 a year, above the field. Academics score well here, yet mobility (35%) and value (20%) carry the most weight, so outcome-per-dollar sets the final position.

Pillar breakdown

Academic
61
Economic
55
Social mobility
Value
41
View full profile →
Is your school on this list? Grab a free, embeddable award badge for your website — it links right back here. Get your badge →

Cut it by what you care about

The same 23 schools, re-ranked by the outcome that matters to you.

Where the programs are

This ranking scores 23 institutions on graduation rates, graduate earnings, debt burdens, and social mobility data from Opportunity Insights. Every data point comes from federal sources. No surveys, no opinions.

Social mobility carries the heaviest weight in our algorithm. We use Raj Chetty's Mobility Report Card — built on 30 million anonymized tax records — to measure whether a college changes a family's economic trajectory across generations. Schools that take low-income students and launch them into higher earnings rank higher than schools that admit wealthy students and take credit for their success.

The transparency penalty matters here. Schools that don't report their data get scored lower than schools that do. If an institution won't show you its numbers, we think you should know that before you write them a tuition check.

The story behind the ranking

A ranking gives you an order; these charts give you the shape. They show how this group of schools spreads across the four things that decide whether a degree pays off — what graduates earn, whether they finish, how far they move up, and what it costs. Look for the standouts, the outliers, and the trade-offs the list alone can't show.

Earnings Outcomes

What graduates earn 10 years after enrolling. Data from College Scorecard.

Distribution of Median Earnings

1 $13K 17 $38K 5 $63K $88K $113K $138K 17 National Avg

Earnings vs. Net Price

Top-left = best value. Top-ranked schools are highlighted.

$10K$65K$120K $25K$50K NET PRICE (lower →) EARNINGS (higher ↑) West Virginia Marshall University Shepherd University Concord University University of

Completion & Access

Graduation rates and who gets in. Data from College Scorecard & IPEDS.

Graduation Rates

West Virginia Univer… 63% Marshall University 50% Shepherd University 50% Concord University 41% University of Charle… 46% West Liberty Univers… 60% West Virginia State … 36% Bluefield State Univ… 36% West Virginia Northe… 31% Southern West Virgin… 27% Glenville State Univ… 35% West Virginia Univer… 34% Fairmont State Unive… 46% BridgeValley Communi… 30% Wheeling University 27% New River Community … 33% Blue Ridge Community… 37% Potomac State Colleg… 28% Eastern West Virgini… 41% Mountwest Community … 18% West Virginia Univer… 20% Pierpont Community a… 40% Valley College-Marti… 62%

Pell Grant Rate vs. Graduation Rate

Right = more low-income students. Higher = more graduate.

0% 100% PELL GRANT RATE → GRAD RATE ↑ West Virginia Marshall University Shepherd University Concord University University of
Social Mobility

What the Mobility Data Says

The backbone of this ranking is social-mobility data from Raj Chetty's Mobility Report Card, which draws on more than 30 million tax records. A school's mobility rate is the share of its students who move from the bottom income quintile to the top. Among the 11 schools on this list with available data, that rate averages 1.4%. Southern West Virginia Community and Technical College leads the group at 2.7%, with Marshall University (1.7%) and Concord University (1.4%) close behind.

Who gets in matters as much as what happens after. Across these schools, an average of 14% of students start in the bottom income quintile. Southern West Virginia Community and Technical College leads at 22.4%, which signals an admissions door that is actually open to low-income students. Schools that pair high access with high mobility are the ones driving generational change.

Once low-income students enroll, their odds of reaching the top income quintile average 11.2% across this list. Marshall University posts the highest success rate at 17.6%. Access without completion and career momentum is an incomplete picture, and this is the number that completes it.

Social capital, measured by economic connectedness, captures the degree of cross-class friendship on campus, another dimension Opportunity Insights ties to long-run outcomes. Across these schools it averages 1.41 against a national benchmark of 1.0. West Virginia University reaches 1.63, the highest on the list.

Mobility, access, and social-capital figures from Raj Chetty's Mobility Report Card & the Opportunity Insights Social Capital Atlas.

Cost & Debt

What families actually pay and what students owe. Data from College Scorecard.

Median Debt at Graduation

7 $6K 14 $18K 2 $30K $42K $54K 14 National Avg

Frequently Asked Questions

Best Online Colleges in West Virginia: Your Questions, Answered

What is the #1 school in the Best Online Colleges in West Virginia ranking? +

West Virginia University in Morgantown, WV ranks #1 in our 2026 Best Online Colleges in West Virginia ranking. It earns the top spot on the strength of a median $55,939 in graduate earnings ten years after enrollment and a 63% graduation rate. Our score is built entirely from federal data on graduation rates, graduate earnings, debt, and social mobility. Reputation surveys play no part.

Which school has the highest graduate earnings? +

Wheeling University posts the highest median earnings on this list: $57,949 ten years after enrollment, well above the $41,349 average across the 23 ranked schools with earnings data. Earnings that outpace cost are what separate a degree that pays off from one that does not.

Which school offers the best value? +

On a pure return-on-cost basis, West Virginia University at Parkersburg leads: graduates earn a median $35,171 against net price of about $1,807 a year, the strongest earnings-to-cost ratio in the ranking. Applicants should weigh that payback against sticker price rather than prestige.

Which school has the highest graduation rate? +

West Virginia University has the highest graduation rate in this ranking at 63%, compared with a 39% average across the list. Completion matters because the students who finish are the ones who actually capture the earnings and mobility gains a degree promises.

How much does it cost to attend these schools? +

The average net price, meaning what students actually pay after grants and scholarships, is about $10,841 a year across the 23 ranked schools with cost data. West Virginia University at Parkersburg is among the most affordable at roughly $1,807. Net price is a far better guide to affordability than the published sticker price.

How is the Best Online Colleges in West Virginia ranking calculated? +

We score every school on a four-pillar algorithm: economic outcomes (graduate earnings and debt), social mobility (Raj Chetty's Mobility Report Card, built on more than 30 million anonymized tax records), academic quality (graduation and retention), and value (net price and loan burden). Social mobility carries the heaviest weight, so schools that lift low-income students into higher earnings rank above those that simply admit wealthy students. Every input comes from federal data, and schools that withhold their numbers are scored lower for it.

How many schools are ranked and where does the data come from? +

This ranking evaluates 23 institutions using the U.S. Department of Education's College Scorecard, the Opportunity Insights Mobility Report Card and Social Capital Atlas, Times Higher Education, and NCES IPEDS. There are no opinion surveys or paid placements. The order is determined by the data alone and refreshed as new federal figures are released.

Sources & Citations

[1]

U.S. Department of Education. College Scorecard Data. Federal Student Aid, National Center for Education Statistics.

[2]

National Center for Education Statistics. Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System (IPEDS).

The State of American Higher Education Outcomes for 2026 — report cover Download PDF

The 2026 Annual Report

The State of American Higher Education Outcomes

Every state graded on what graduates earn, how far they climb, and what college really costs — the hidden geography of economic mobility, in one report.

Free · 21 pages · 5,745 institutions · 100% federal data, no surveys